A share buyback (or stock repurchase) occurs when a company uses its own capital to buy back its shares from existing shareholders in the open market or via a tender offer. Reducing the number of shares outstanding, the company effectively consolidates ownership among the remaining shareholders.
Put simply, if a company repurchases 10% of its shares , each remaining investor’s stake in the company’s earnings rises by a little more than 10%.
Companies may repurchase shares for several reasons, but the result is usually to enhance shareholder value. Management often sees buybacks as a smart use of cash if they believe the stock is undervalued or if there are limited opportunities to reinvest profits into growth initiatives. Some companies borrow money to fund buybacks when interest rates are low, as the cost of debt can be less than the value created by reducing the share count.
A buyback also allows firms to return cash to shareholders while maintaining flexibility, unlike dividends, which the company and shareholders may believe is an obligation. In addition, many companies use buybacks to offset the impact of new shares issued through employee stock programs, helping protect the value of existing shares.
In the first half of 2025, S&P 500 companies spent a record $528.1 billion on stock repurchases, about 1% of all shares outstanding. Annualized, that pace would equal more than 2% of the index’s market value. By itself these buybacks would lift earnings per share growth by roughly 2% a year even if profits did not increase.
Company participation was widespread, with ~72% of the 500 companies buying back at least $10 million in stock in the first half of 2025. However, much like the index’s market cap concentration, buybacks were heavily concentrated as the 20 largest firms accounted for 49.7% of all repurchases, or about $262 billion of the total.
Warren Buffett once said, “When stock can be bought below a business’s value, it is probably the best use of cash.” That idea captures the essence of buybacks: they can be a powerful tool for creating shareholder value, but only when done wisely. Buybacks are often viewed as a sign of management’s confidence in the company’s future, signaling to investors that leadership believes the stock is undervalued while also serving as a way to return capital. Yet like any strategy, they come with trade-offs.
At GHPIA, we believe repurchases at attractive prices can lift long-term value, but buybacks done at high valuations or simply to boost short-term metrics can backfire. The key is to judge buybacks not by their size but by whether they genuinely strengthen long-term shareholder value.
A share buyback, or stock repurchase, occurs when a company uses its own capital to buy back shares from existing shareholders either on the open market or through a tender offer. This reduces the number of shares outstanding, consolidating ownership among remaining shareholders. For example, if a company buys back 10% of its shares, each remaining shareholder’s stake in company earnings increases by slightly more than 10%
Companies repurchase shares primarily to increase shareholder value. A buyback reduces the number of shares in circulation, so each share represents a larger claim on company profits. Management often sees buybacks as a prudent use of cash when the stock is undervalued or when growth reinvestment opportunities are limited. Some companies borrow at low interest rates to fund buybacks if the cost of debt is lower than the value created. Buybacks provide flexibility since, unlike dividends, they don’t create a recurring obligation. Moreover, buybacks offset dilution from employee stock programs, helping to protect shareholder value.
In 2025, share buybacks by S&P 500 companies reached record levels, with $293.5 billion spent in Q1 and $234.6 billion in Q2—a 20% decline but still historically strong. Buybacks accounted for about 1% of outstanding shares in the first half of the year, potentially increasing earnings per share by about 2% annually on average independent of profit growth. Buyback concentration increased with the top 20 firms responsible for nearly half of all repurchases. Market uncertainties like tariffs and economic policy caused some pullback in Q2, but participation remained broad and supportive. Projections indicate buybacks and dividends together will set new records for shareholder returns in 2025
Warren Buffett’s wisdom sums it up: “When stock can be bought below a business’s value, it is probably the best use of cash.” Buybacks done at the right price create long-term shareholder value and signal management confidence. However, buybacks aimed solely at boosting short-term stock metrics or done at high valuations can hurt investors. The critical test isn’t how large a buyback is, but whether it genuinely strengthens long-term shareholder value, aligning with sound investment principles.
Get in touch to schedule a conversation. There is no cost or obligation to explore your next step.
Top Row L to R: Brad Engle, Mike Sullivan, Sebrina Ivey, Christian Lewton, Jason Kitner
Bottom Row L to R: Carin Wagner, Angela Kennedy Lee, Jenny Merges, Brian Friedman, Deirdre Mcguire, Barbara Terrazas, Reed McCoy